While 2022 tight end class was heralded for its depth, the top end of the Class of 2023 is on another level as there are several prospects that will provide legitimate first-round excitement in this class. All five prospects on this list have legitimate potential to be runners-up at worst.
1. Michael Mayer, Notre Dame (Junior)
2021 statistics | Goals | Rec | meter | TD | DP | MTF | rec class |
Michael Mayr | 95 | 71 | 840 | 7 | 3 | 8th | 82 |
The learning curve at the tight end of college is very similar to that in the NFL, which means it’s difficult to contribute early, but don’t say that to Notre Dame’s leading receiver over the past two seasons.
Mayer is the rare tight end prospect who’s ready for the NFL as a real sophomore. No, he may not run like Kyle Pitts and won’t go nearly as high, but he can play an inline role that Pitts can never fill.
MICHAEL MAYER IS A GROWN MAN ????@NDFootball pic.twitter.com/PYxL9SlF1l
— PFF College (@PFF_College) November 28, 2021
Don’t get it twisted though, he’s not a stiff receiver. What he lacks in sheer explosiveness, Mayer makes up for in physicality. He has a knack for making contact on his paths before pinning defenders to his jersey on his breaks. If he looks clouded, it won’t be for long.
It’s scary to imagine that at just 20 years old he’s already acting like the worst guy on the field. What will he look like in the league in a few years?
Michael Mayer: 91.2 in last three weeks of season, highest among all tight ends???? pic.twitter.com/QiHdJezwkw
— PFF College (@PFF_College) December 23, 2021
2. Dalton Kincaid, Utah (RS Senior)
2021 statistics | Goals | Rec | meter | TD | DP | MTF | rec class |
Dalton Kincaid | 45 | 36 | 510 | 8th | 1 | 83.2 |
If Mayer is #1 in this class for refined receiving ability, then Kincaid is #1B. Kincaid’s background as a former receiver recruit is evident. He spent two seasons at the University of San Diego, where he was a sophomore FCS All-American after amassing 44 catches for 835 yards. He transferred to Utah in the COVID year, where he had a 2021 breakout season.
The way he gets off the scrimmage line, as well as the way he gets in and out of his breaks, is exactly what evaluators want from a next-level receiving weapon. He’s got some damn good hands too, not losing a single pass on 37 occasions in Utah last season while going 7-for-9 on contested occasions last season. He’s a bit older as a fifth-year player, but Kincaid has likely returned to further revamp his former wide receiver frame as he’s still listed on the smaller side at 6-foot-4 and 242 pounds.
3. Arik Gilbert, Georgia (RS sophomore)
Statistics 2020* | Goals | Rec | meter | TD | DP | MTF | rec class |
Arike Gilbert | 53 | 35 | 368 | 2 | 2 | 9 | 73 |
Gilbert really shouldn’t even be on this list – just his name at the bottom with an asterisk next to it – because he should be #1 from a talent perspective. And from a “what’s wrong with him off the field” perspective, we don’t even know when he’ll be playing football again.
Gilbert was a five-star player and one of the top-rated tight end recruits of all time in 2020. The 6-foot-5, 248-pound sports prodigy originally brought his talents to Baton Rouge, where he had 35 catches for 368 yards scored as a true freshman.
Arik Gilbert turned 19 today.
Consider this a reminder of what he did against all SEC competitions as an 18-year-old (via @SECFootballVids). pic.twitter.com/2fpU7l4w0P
— Connor O’Gara (@cjogara) February 22, 2021
Then things took a turn. After entering the transfer portal, Gilbert originally committed to Florida before retiring and joining Georgia. He was never used for the national champion because he missed the entire 2021 season for personal reasons. Gilbert reportedly weighed over 300 pounds when he returned to the team in January this year. While he looked more groomed at the time of the Bulldogs’ spring game, NFL teams must do their due diligence on where Gilbert is off the field when he finally declares.
4. Jaheim Bell, SC (Junior)
2021 statistics | Goals | Rec | meter | TD | DP | MTF | rec class |
Jaheim bell | 41 | 30 | 488 | 5 | 1 | 13 | 88.8 |
Ball in hand, Bell is the best tight end in the country. So much so that South Carolina gave him seven handoffs last season! And that’s not even including this 65-yarder that was recalled.
AND IT’S VERSATILE TOO!! Here he lines up at FB and hosts a big run for a TD. Unfortunately it was called back. I tell you all Jaheim Bell is a name to remember pic.twitter.com/QqFIHn9NK3
— Tyler Browning (@DiabeticTyler) September 6, 2021
Not only is he elusive with 13 broken tackles from just 30 receptions, he’s also explosive. Of his five touchdown receptions in 2021, three came from over 65 yards.
JAHEIM BELL HOUSE CALL
“Pour some mayo all over me baby!” ???? pic.twitter.com/Z2jfGrFRHi
— SEC Network (@SECNetwork) December 30, 2021
The only problem is that at 6ft 3 and 230 pounds, he’s still built more like a running back than a true tight end. If he can put 10-15 pounds of good weight on his body, he’ll be a desirable moving pawn in the NFL.
5. Sam LaPorta, Iowa (senior)
2021 statistics | Goals | Rec | meter | TD | DP | MTF | rec class |
Sam Laporta | 81 | 53 | 670 | 3 | 5 | 10 | 80 |
LaPorta would easily have been in as a top-five tight end in last year’s class if he had declared, but there’s good reason to think he can boost his stock significantly as a senior. LaPorta moves so smoothly for a man his size, which we’ve seen on the course as LaPorta has rushed for 245 yards in his last three games.
Sam LaPorta led the Big 10 TEs last season in…
???? catches (53)
???? meters (670)
???? Meters after catch (299)
???? Meters after contact (206)
???? Catches over 15 yards (18)pic.twitter.com/wanw3qzxBE— PFF College (@PFF_College) May 12, 2022
With that kind of natural ability, LaPorta could be ranked much higher as a prospect if he cleans up a few things. The first problem he needs to fix is his drops, as he’s let eight of 88 catchables slip through his hands over the past two seasons. The second is his route run, where he still doesn’t look good enough to run a full route tree. Given Kirk Ferentz’s history of designing tight ends, I’d have faith that LaPorta would look a lot better in 2022.